Pharisees Condemn The Adulterous Woman

In Seattle, a 14-year old boy was found guilty of first degree murder and of five counts of robbery and one of attempted robbery. The Superior Court Judge, Charles Z. Smith, broke down and wept as he sentenced the boy. It is most unusual for a judge to weep over his cases. (Encyc … More

Condemnation
In this passage we find the Jewish religious leaders trying to set a trap. They brought a woman to Christ whom they said had been caught in adultery (v. 3). They said, “Teacher, this woman was caught sleeping with a man who isn’t her husband. The Law of Moses teaches that a woman like this should be stoned to death! What do you say” (vv. 4-6)? If He answered that the woman should be stoned, He would have been violating the Roman law which forbade such acts. If He said that she should not be stoned, He would be violating Moses’ law (Deuteronomy 22:24). Finally, He stood up and said, “If any of you have never sinned, then go ahead and throw the first stone at her” (v. 7)! Basically there are four reasons why Jesus did not command that this woman be stoned:
  1. The Jews had no right to take the death penalty into their own hands. The civil rule of Israel was under the jurisdiction of the Roman Empire.
  2. The dishonest  intent of those who brought the woman was obvious. This was evidenced by the rude way these religious leaders interrupted Jesus.
  3. The law required that both the man and the woman found in adultery be stoned (Lev. 20:10; Deut. 22:22) and not just the woman. There is no mention of the man that was involved.
  4. It was required by Jewish law that the accusers cast the first stones (Deuteronomy 17:7).  In answering His accusers, Christ applied this law to the lives of those who accused the woman.

Instead of passing judgment on the woman, Jesus simply judged the judges. By applying the Law to the woman and not to themselves, these leaders violated both the letter and the spirit of the Law.

Application

If  I had been in the crowd when the woman caught in adultery was brought to Jesus, I wonder which of the following I would have done?

  1. ____ Stood up for the woman.
  2. ____ Picked up a stone.
  3. ____ Looked the other way.
  4. ____ Prayed for the woman.

John 8:1-7 (English Standard Version)

View this passage in NIV (Bible Gateway) »

More John commentaries

John 5:1-15
Man Healed at the Pool of Bethesda

John 5:16-23
Jesus Claims to be God

John 5:24-29
Four Types of Resurrections

John 5:30-38
Jesus’ Witnesses of his Diety

John 5:39-47
Blindness to the Truth of the Scriptures

John 6:1-14
Philip Fails the Exam

John 6:15-27
Jesus Calms Their Fears

John 6:30-40
What’s Your Motive for Following Jesus

John 6:36-44
The Reaction of The Jews

John 6:45-55
Drawn to Christ

John 6:56-59
Confusion of The Body And Blood of Christ

John 6:60-71
Rejection by Many Followers

John 7:1-14
The Advice of Jesus’ Brothers

John 7:15-24
Judge Rightly

John 7:25-29
Jesus Origin

John 7:30-36
Blinded to The Truth

John 7:37-53
Divided Opinions About Jesus

John 8:1-7
Pharisees Condemn The Adulterous Woman

John 8:8-11
Jesus Forgives The Adulterous Women

John 8:12-20
Jesus is The Light of The World

John 8:21-30
Jesus Predicts His Death

John 8:31-38
The Truth Will Set You Free

John 8:39-47
You Are of Your Father The Devil

John 8:48-59
Jesus’ Claims To His Identity

John 9:1-12
Contentment in Any Circumstance

John 9:13-23
Trouble with the Jewish Leaders

John 9:24-34
The Testimony of the Healed Man

John 9:35-41
The Pharisees Blindless

John 10:1-13
The True Shepherd

John 10:14-21
The Good Shephard Knows His Sheep

John 10:22-30
Rejected by the Religious Leaders

John 10:31-42
Renewed Efforts to Stone Jesus

John 11:1-6
News of Lazarus’ Death

John 11:7-16
The Disciples Warn Jesus About Going to Judea

John 11:17-27
Jesus Arrives at Mary and Martha’s House

John 11:28-37
Emotions of Jesus

John 11:38-44
Jesus Calls Lazarus Forth From the Grave

John 11:45-57
Jesus Withdraws to Ephraim