The Pharisees Ask Jesus For a Sign From Heaven

People refuse to believe that which they don’t want to believe, in spite of evidence. When explorers first went to Australia they found a mammal which laid eggs; spent some time in water, some on land; had a broad, flat tail, webbed feet, and a bill similar to a duck. Upon … More


The willful unbelief of the Pharisees disturbed the Lord to the depths of His spirit. They’re demanding to see a sign was not due to their desire to see the hand of God but because they were blind to His hand. The Biblical order for a Christian should be that “believing is seeing” and not “seeing is believing” (v.17).

Jesus once more seeks privacy with His disciples by getting in a boat with them crossing the Sea of Galilee to the district of Dalmanutha (v. 10). The Pharisees came out and started an argument with Jesus (v. 11) They wanted to test Him by asking for a sign from heaven. He asked why they are always looking for a sign from heaven and promised them that they will not be given one (vv. 12-13). He took advantage of this opportunity by warning them of the hypocrisy, pride, worldliness and legalistic spirit of the religious leaders. He was saying, “Don’t you go the same way the Pharisees and Herod have already gone.” At this point the disciples seemed very concerned that they had forgotten to bring enough to eat and they were going to be hungry (vv. 14-16). Jesus reminded them that twice He had satisfied the hunger of huge crowds and had food leftover. His question was why did they forget so quickly and why were they so slow in learning (vv. 17-21)?

If we would only learn the lessons of experience, it would teach us not the pessimism of the things that cannot be, but the hope which stands amazed that God has brought us thus far in safety and in certainty and the confidence that God can bring us through anything that may happen.


What is it that makes it difficult for me to sometimes hear and accept spiritual things? What is something I have heard over and over and know that I should do and as yet have not put it into practice? Lord help me to be a person who accepts spiritual teaching and puts it into practice.

Mark 8:10-21 (English Standard Version)

Warning: MagpieRSS: Failed to parse RSS file. (Space required at line 39, column 24) in /var/www/html/familytimes/includes/magpie6-1/ on line 230

Warning: array_slice() expects parameter 1 to be array, null given in /var/www/html/familytimes/includes/rss/esvLookup.php on line 15

View this passage in NIV (Bible Gateway) »

More Mark commentaries

Mark 5:1-10
The Demon Possessed Man at Gerasa

Mark 5:11-20
Two Thousand Hogs Drown

Mark 5:21-34
Hemorrhaging Woman Healed

Mark 5:35-43
Jesus Heals Jairus Daughter

Mark 6:1-6
Jesus Returns to His Home Town of Nazareth

Mark 6:7-13
Jesus Sends His Disciples as Missionaries

Mark 6:14-29
Mark Tells About The Death of John The Baptist

Mark 6:30-44
Feeding of The 5000

Mark 6:45-52
Storm on The Sea of Galilee

Mark 6:53-56
Crowd Wanting to be Healed

Mark 7:1-13
Conflict With The Religious Leaders Over Laws

Mark 7:14-23
Jesus Attacks a System of Rules And Regulations

Mark 7:24-30
Jesus Casts a Demon Out of a Gentile Daughter

Mark 7:31-37
Jesus Heals a Deaf Man With a Speech Impediment

Mark 8:1-9
Jesus Feeds 4000 With 7 Baskets Leftover

Mark 8:10-21
The Pharisees Ask Jesus For a Sign From Heaven

Mark 8:22-30
Jesus Heals a Blind Man Gradually

Mark 8:31-38
Jesus Warns His Disciples That He is Going to Die

Mark 9:1-8
Jesus Takes 3 of His Disciples To a High Mountain

Mark 9:9-13
Three Disciples Question About The Transfiguration

Mark 9:14-29
The Disciples Are Helpless And Ineffective

Mark 9:30-37
Disciples Arguing About Who is The Greatest

Mark 9:38-50
Jesus Says Greatness Comes From Serving Others

Mark 10:1-12
Is it Lawful For a Man to Divorce His Wife?

Mark 10:13-22
Possessions Don’t Help You Obtain Eternal Life

Mark 10:23-31
Hard For The Rich to Enter The Kingdom of God

Mark 10:32-45
Willingness to Give Extra Service

Mark 10:46-52
Every Male Jew Must Attend Passover

Mark 11:1-11
Jesus Rides a Donkey Into Jerusalem on Palm Sunday

Mark 11:12-18
Jesus Said The Temple is a Den of Thieves

Mark 11:19-26
Jesus Cursed The Fig Tree And it Dried Up

Mark 11:27-33
Jesus Questioned on His Authority